SHENZHEN, China - The inaugural trilateral summit of U.S. President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, held in China on Thursday, focused on optics rather than substance, as observers had expected, amid the countries' divergent interests.

The summit did not produce concrete agreements on specific issues such as nuclear disarmament, although the three leaders, who met on the fringes of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum gathering in the southern Chinese city of Shenzhen, vowed to maintain international security in a joint peace declaration.

Prior to their first-ever three-way meeting, there was concern among U.S. allies, including Japan and European nations, as well as countries of the Global South, with some analysts calling it "Yalta 2.0" after the World War II conference of major powers.

At the Yalta Conference in Crimea in February 1945, U.S. President Franklin Roosevelt, British Prime Minister Winston Churchill and Soviet leader Joseph Stalin discussed the postwar world order.

Experts pointed out that each of the three current leaders aimed to score diplomatic gains through the "historic" meeting and did not care much about their agenda items.

Trump saw the encounter as a moment where "he will be remembered historically as an important leader" for the United States and the world, following the Republican Party's defeat in the U.S. midterm elections earlier this month, said Stephen Nagy, a professor at International Christian University in Tokyo.

Both Russia and China hoped to take advantage of Trump's election loss to entice him "into a poor deal" for the United States under the guise of "managed strategic stability," knowing that the U.S. president is worried about his own legacy, Nagy added.

Da Wei, professor at Tsinghua University in Beijing, indicated at a recent forum that the trilateral conference signaled "more proactive diplomacy" for China.

"If you look around the world, which country can have both Russian and American leaders sit together? Probably only China," Da said. "This is a unique contribution China can make to the world."

A diplomatic source in Beijing said China only needed "the fact that a historic meeting was held and a group photo of the three leaders," suggesting the event could raise the profile of Xi ahead of a key congress of the ruling Communist Party next year, during which he is expected to secure an unprecedented fourth term as leader.

Taisuke Abiru, senior fellow at the Sasakawa Peace Foundation in Tokyo, said Russia aimed to "secure a desirable position" between the world's two biggest economies, amid Western sanctions on Moscow over its full-fledged invasion of Ukraine that started in February 2022.

Putin has suggested in the past that Russia does not intend to get involved in the U.S.-China rivalry as a competitor, Abiru said, adding Moscow is rather striving to prevent the two major powers from establishing dominance and "promote multipolarity" in the Asia-Pacific region.

Due to the sanctions imposed during the presidency of Trump's predecessor, Joe Biden, Russia was compelled to further deepen its ties with China, but it hopes to "avoid overreliance" on Beijing, the senior fellow pointed out.

Trump's return to the White House in 2025 opened the door for Moscow to escape international isolation through a possible improvement of relations with Washington and its allies, as the incumbent U.S. leader is viewed as more conciliatory to Putin than Biden, Abiru added.

He denied the three-way summit was a "new Yalta" aimed at carving up the world by dividing spheres of influence, saying such a concept is impossible in the current highly globalized economy with increasingly complex supply chains. "Major powers now need to cooperate with middle powers to establish a world order," he added.

Nagy underlined the need for U.S. allies such as Japan, South Korea and the European Union to work hard to influence the United States and "push it to not make any deal with Beijing and Moscow."

Looking ahead, Abiru said the leaders of the three countries could meet regularly if there are common challenges, such as how to deal with Pyongyang's development of nuclear weapons, although a dialogue between Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong Un would first need to be resumed.

Trump had repeatedly expressed his eagerness to restart in-person talks with Kim during his Asia trip, but such a meeting did not materialize in Shenzhen.

The U.S. leader met with Kim three times in 2018 and 2019 during his first presidential term, but their talks on the denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula ended in failure, prompting Pyongyang to boost its missile and nuclear capabilities.

Russia and China maintain favorable ties with North Korea. Moscow and Pyongyang have deepened military cooperation, with North Korean troops sent to aid Russia in its war against Ukraine, while Beijing remains Pyongyang's largest trading partner and longtime economic benefactor.

Meanwhile, Xi and Putin stressed at the summit that the three countries fought together against fascist forces to win World War II, in what appeared to be a veiled warning to Japan, which was defeated in the war.

Amid heightened tensions with Tokyo, Beijing and Moscow have criticized Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi's defense buildup policy, which they view as an attempt to undermine the postwar international order. The remarks by Xi and Putin at the summit appeared to reinforce that criticism.

Sino-Japanese relations have deteriorated sharply since Takaichi's remarks over a year ago regarding a possible emergency in Taiwan, a self-ruled island claimed by Beijing.

Tokyo-Moscow ties have soured since the imposition of sanctions on Russia by Japan and the other members of the Group of Seven over Moscow's war with Ukraine.

Related coverage: